Mega IPOs underline the value of advice

Advisers can offer a considered perspective to investors who want to rush into IPOs.

The fact that Australia is a key non-US market for Anthropic’s initial public offering may trigger a range of questions from clients for which advisers should be prepared.

The highly anticipated IPO of Claude’s developer may be among the biggest in history and follows the US$1.97 trillion Nasdaq listing of Elon Musk-founded SpaceX in June 2026. 

The artificial intelligence (AI) IPO boom may not end with Anthropic either. Companies like OpenAI, TikTok owner ByteDance, payments platform Stripe and software company Databricks are reported to be moving towards public markets too.

Questions from investors may not be restricted to just an IPO itself. Those who are unable to gain access to the float may express interest in purchasing shares in secondary trading or via exchange traded funds.

The first role of advisers may be to temper the hype that can attract clients to big-name IPOs, instead encouraging them to consider an opportunity in the broader context of an overall investment strategy.

The prospects of individual companies following their listing obviously vary on a case-by-case basis. But a body of research suggests investing in an IPO, or immediately afterwards, on the simple basis that early investors will reap the gains is not necessarily sound logic.

“Interest does not automatically make an IPO suitable, but it gives advisers an opportunity to test the idea against the client strategy. Having a global view of client opportunities and being front foot in those conversations are key to being selective with respect to mega IPOs.” says David Harvie, Director of Wholesale Distribution at AUSIEX.

A recent analysis of 650 ASX IPOs over the past decade by Morningstar is the latest to show a successful IPO does not necessarily translate into a successful long-term investment.

“First, 'stag profits' are real. The median stock pops 5% in its first session. The average day-one return, about 15%, is higher, as the distribution is right-skewed by a tail of (mostly small) stocks that do very well,” Morningstar senior market strategist Lochlan Halloway wrote in June this year.

“But if we track the same basket of ASX entrants beyond their first day, history suggests enthusiasm wanes pretty quickly. By day 30, the median stock is basically breaking even for IPO subscribers. At the six-month mark, it’s fallen to a 10% loss. And a year later? Down almost 20% on its IPO price.”

He points out this shouldn’t rule out investing in IPOs altogether, stating that “every public company must float at some point: some are genuinely good and will perform”. 

The results back up studies about global IPOs which suggest equity investing isn’t necessarily about buying shares on the first day a company lists, but instead making considered decisions over time about which stocks to hold. 

Fund manager Dimensional, for example, studied the first-year performance of more than 6,000 US IPOs from 1991 to 2018 and found they generally underperformed industry benchmarks.

Dimensional says the outsized stock returns commonly associated with a company’s first day of trading may not be attainable by all investors – due to an allocation process which typically favours institutions over retail investors.

The sample for its study consisted of 6,362 IPOs from January 1991 to December 2018 for which data was available. 

The findings showed that IPOs underperformed the Russell 3000 Index in all periods examined. For example, IPOs generated an annualised compound return of 6.93% over the full sample periods, as compared to 9.13% for the Russell 3000 index over the same time horizon.

The practical lesson is to step back and consider a company’s prospects, as well as the case for holding it in individual portfolios, separately from the publicity surrounding its listing. 

“Despite Anthropic’s size and scale, investors should be mindful of letting their portfolios become too concentrated in the AI trade. While Anthropic’s IPO would be historic, investors should stick to their broader investment plans and avoid seeing these stocks as a ticket to quick riches,” says Cameron Gleeson, Head of Investment Strategy at Betashares.

If clients remain eager to hold Anthropic after its IPO and it is appropriate for them, ETFs may provide a route to gain diversified exposure to the company over time. The time period in which it may appear in an ETF, though, will depend on the latter’s investment strategy and the index which it tracks.

To be included in the S&P500, for example, a company must meet certain criteria. These include a requirement that a company must be publicly traded for at least 12 months before inclusion in the index, and that it passes financial viability screens.

“The bottom line? Having these conversations with clients early can help demonstrate the value of advice and provide a foundation for strategic investments in this space” concludes David Harvie.

The overarching message to clients may be that patience generally pays off when investing – a rule of thumb that may apply as much to today’s mega IPOs as it does to other investment opportunities.

 

Stay up to date with the latest insights - sign up to the monthly AXIS email newsletter.

 

Share: